July 16, 2009

Creative Licensing

0 comments
I've played a good number of role-playing games, and most editions of D&D, and I really like how 4th Edition Dungeons & Dragons goes a long way in making sure that players have a lot of options on their plate. Most of these options are determined by race and class, though there is a short-list of things that every can at least make an attempt for (grab, bull rush, and melee/ranged basic attacks, for example).
I enjoy this design move because it provides a lot of thematic and effective decisions for players, so anyone playing the game has an understanding of what it is they can do, or what they should be doing. This is great for new players, or even veterans playing a new class.

What about "non-standard" maneuvers, however? Stuff like swinging from a chandelier, knocking over a book case, or dropping a tapestry on the bad guys. Most of my players tend to overlook the environment and just use what they know works, and honestly I think this is a syndrome of playing in older D&D editions where in most cases it was a bad idea to try something off the cuff. You never tried to make a grapple in 3rd Edition because it was very hard to pull off, and when you got it to work you wondered why you'd bothered since it didnt really seem to do much.
The same thing could be said for many non-standard actions, which probably required several very difficult rolls (if a roll is even called for) and amounted to some damage...you got better and more reliable results with your standard array of swords and spells.

When I design encounters, I try to put in some interesting environment elements that the players or monsters can work with. I then decide what I should immediately inform them about, or use their "passive" skills to determine what they should know. I might point out a book case, for example, and tell them that it can be knocked over. I might just mention it and wait until they try to use it...but I might also use it on them. For things like fungus, or glowing crytals, I rely on the passive skill. If its high enough, I'll tell them what it does. If not, they need to call for a roll to see if they can puzzle it out.

Case in point, in the first Songs of Erui adventure, there is a chamber with a massive glowing crystal set in the floor. Grynn was able to determine that it could be used to channel cold magic, assuming one could harness it and direct it. When they got attack by undead, some of the casters started doing just that, and proceeded to ransack the chamber with ice blasts. Once Grey and Grynn got them away from the crystal, Grynn took over and started using it against the bad guys.
Of course, some players like to throw things at you that you werent expecting. I've said it before: Josh is one of the players I can count on to always try something really bizarre or different, about once per game (if not more). He pitches me an idea, and I give him the odds. Sometimes its easy to figure out a mechanic, but sometimes not so much. It doesnt always work, but thats the fun of risk versus reward.
For example, how about a flying drop kick? Gimme an Acrobatics or Athletics, and Strength vs. AC roll, and you'll deal 1d4 + Str mod damage. If you succeed on the skill roll, you'll also knock the guy prone (and if you succeed very well, you wont fall prone). All in all, it adds another die roll to the attack routine, and doesnt give him an awesome attack that is better than his usual fare: its effective and fun.

Mostly, I have a hard time wanting to allow non-standard actions that dont rely on the environment, because I'm concerned that some players might try to do it all the time. I actually give them a clause in many situations, "I'll allow it for now, but I reserve the right to prevent you from doing so in the future. If you're okay with that, lets continue."
Its easier to allow Grynn to channel powerful beams of cold energy when he has to make Arcana checks and touch a massive crystal set in a chamber. If he could use Arcana all the time to do something like that, well...its basically like giving out another at-will attack.

One thing I'll make clear in case I havent before: I'm not a fan of arbitrary decisions and resolutions. I'm not going to let any character give it a shot, and just say it works, say it doesnt, or even give them the same odds. You want to push over a book case onto some monsters? The strong characters are going to have a better shot at it than, say, most wizards. Similarly, if you want to swing from a chandelier then you'd better be pretty damned acrobatic, otherwise you're going to fail.
I'm more than willing to let my players try creative actions that arent covered by the rules. This does not mean it will work, or even be as easy. It might require an extra roll to see if we can even get to the next step, or to avoid having something bad happen to the character.
You wanna use thorn whip to pull a fellow team member out of a bad spot? They're going to take damage. You want to use thorn whip to create a rope for a fellow team mate to climb out of a pit? Gimme a Nature check and we'll use that in place of an Athletics check to Aid Another. If you roll bad, they'll take damage (or perhaps even fall from grabbing thorny parts of the whip).
Of course, if druids start abusing thorn whip for all manner of bizarre instances, then I wont let them do it anymore.

I think the best way to encourage your players to do things other than whats covered by powers is to start out by making such extra options very clear for them. If they decide to give it a shot, make sure they know what check(s) will be used, and at least what general effect it will have. For best results, try to make it stuff that will give what they can already do an extra oomph, or so that the damage is roughly on par/adds a condition that they cannot easily do.
A falling book case, for example, might deal "okay" damage, but knock the target prone and immobilize them for one turn. Thats something that most Strength-based characters will want to use, since they cannot easily do those effects with an at-will attack. Hell, you might say that the books grant a one-time attack bonus with a Fire effect and/or bonus fire damage.

Leave a Reply

Labels

5th edition (191) dnd next (152) homebrew (109) review (91) Dragon (79) play report (55) eberron (44) playtest (41) character concepts (32) wandering monsters (32) Dungeon (31) legends and lore (29) legend and lore (28) game design (27) a sundered world (26) monsters (26) aberrant (24) dark sun (24) essentials (24) rant (22) DnD Essentials (21) at the mines of madness (20) class acts (20) monster (20) preview (20) blog (19) dragons eye view (19) songs of erui (19) keep on the shadowfell (17) mapping (17) thunderspire labyrinth (17) shadow marches (16) warlock (16) heroes of shadow (15) report (15) excerpt (14) feats (14) gamma world (14) mike mearls (14) the heirs of ruin (14) adventure (13) adventure path (13) DDI (12) ddm (12) tendrils of fate (12) winning races (12) art (11) races (11) clerics (10) arcane power (9) fighters (9) goodman games (9) magic items (9) minis (9) shardpit (9) skills (9) sorcerer (9) wizard (9) Athas (8) design and development (8) dungeon world (8) monk (8) ranger (8) the chaos scar (8) barbarian (7) dnd encounters (7) druid (7) dungeons and dragons (7) forgotten realms (7) monster vault (7) new powers (7) paladin (7) powers (7) rule-of-three (7) silent 7seven (7) the shadows over greyshore (7) themes (7) ampersand (6) beta (6) campaign (6) houserules (6) lair assault (6) map (6) maps (6) novel (6) previews (6) psion (6) revenant (6) rules (6) tiefling (6) update (6) virtual table (6) adventure tools (5) artificer (5) board game (5) character builder (5) classes (5) delve (5) duergar (5) ecology (5) epiro (5) exploits (5) familiars (5) healing (5) heroes of the forgotten kingdoms (5) living spell (5) march of the phantom brigade (5) monte cook (5) mordenkainen's magnificent mansion (5) psionic (5) rogue (5) undead (5) vampire (5) adamantine dragon (4) arcane (4) assassin (4) bard (4) calendar (4) creature incarnations (4) digital games (4) dungeon crawl classics (4) eladrin (4) encounters (4) expedition to castle ravenloft (4) fey (4) fortune cards (4) gamer's library (4) gnome (4) heroes of the feywild (4) heroic tier (4) hexblades (4) into dragon's den (4) maneuvers (4) mythbusting (4) online tools (4) ravenloft (4) rituals (4) shaman (4) star pact (4) starter set (4) theme (4) unearthed arcana (4) Scions of Punjar (3) adventure log (3) angels (3) awesome (3) backgrounds (3) balic (3) bladesinger (3) book of vile darkness (3) bullywugs (3) class (3) critical failures (3) dangerous delves (3) devil (3) divine power (3) dragon age (3) dragons (3) drow (3) dungeon master (3) dungeon tiles (3) eberron player's guide (3) errata (3) excerpts (3) feywild (3) fighter (3) forum (3) game mechanics (3) gencon (3) greyshore (3) infernal pact (3) legion of gold (3) minotaur (3) monster manual 2 (3) multiclass (3) multiclassing (3) neverwinter (3) owlbear (3) paizo (3) pathfinder rpg (3) ph2 (3) ph3 (3) players handbook 2 (3) prerelease (3) primal (3) psionics (3) quori (3) rebuilding (3) roleplaying (3) rust monster (3) summoning (3) terrain features (3) tieflings (3) warforged (3) warlord (3) wizards (3) 3rd Edition (2) 4e (2) 4e conversion (2) Tokens (2) adventure format (2) age of worms (2) anime (2) announcement (2) avenger (2) background (2) bards (2) beholders (2) bloodlines (2) bugbear (2) cairn of the winter king (2) channel divinity (2) character building (2) character sheet (2) class compendium (2) closed beta (2) combat (2) compilation (2) concept art (2) cosmic (2) customization (2) dcc (2) death (2) debut (2) demon (2) demonologist (2) demonomicon (2) deva (2) divine (2) dming (2) domain of dread (2) dragonborn (2) dragonmarks (2) dungeoncraft (2) dwarf (2) edition (2) editorial (2) elemental chaos (2) elf (2) epic destiny (2) episode (2) erui (2) executioner (2) expertise dice (2) famine in far-go (2) far realm (2) free rpg day (2) gith (2) gnoll (2) goblins (2) half-orc (2) halflings (2) hit points (2) human (2) hybrid (2) hybrid classes (2) interview (2) july (2) knight (2) knightfall games (2) know your role (2) kobold quarterly (2) kobolds (2) lizardfolk (2) lycanthrope (2) magic (2) martial (2) mechanics (2) mind flayer (2) modrons (2) monster builder (2) monster design (2) monster manual 3 (2) morale (2) mummy (2) narrative (2) odnd (2) open grave (2) otyugh (2) paladins (2) paragon path (2) pathfinder (2) pixie (2) play by post (2) player's handbook (2) player's handbook 3 (2) players handbook heroes (2) poll (2) power play (2) psionic power (2) psychic (2) race (2) raggamoffyn (2) random (2) red dragon (2) sentinel (2) shaper (2) shardmind (2) skill challenges (2) slayer (2) spells (2) star cult (2) stress test (2) table of contents (2) tendriles of fate (2) the hydra's grave (2) the shadowfell (2) the wayward wyrmling (2) treasure parcels (2) troglodytes (2) updates (2) vampire class (2) weapons (2) web tools (2) wilden (2) wrath of ashardalon (2) 0-level characters (1) 2011 (1) 5th (1) Amethyst (1) Battlemaps (1) Burnt Offerings (1) Deus Ex Machina (1) Dragon 383 (1) Gond (1) Jaroo (1) MAD (1) NPCs (1) Theater (1) Timesus the black star (1) Ultramodern4 (1) Underdark (1) a heros first steps (1) aberration (1) ability score modifiers (1) ability scores (1) abyssal plague (1) acamar (1) accessory (1) action economy (1) advancement (1) adventurer's vault 2 (1) adventuring armies (1) advice (1) aerenal (1) against the giants (1) alchemy (1) alignment (1) analysis (1) ankheg (1) annoucements (1) april (1) april fools (1) arcane heroes (1) arcane heroes 3 (1) arcanist (1) archivist (1) archons (1) ardent (1) arms race (1) asian (1) aspects (1) assassin devil (1) astral sea (1) atari (1) august and beyond (1) avandra (1) banderhobb (1) baphomet (1) barovia (1) basilisk (1) bat (1) battle clerics (1) battlemind (1) bazaar of the bizarre (1) beard quills (1) beastmaster (1) beholder collector set (1) belgoi (1) best of the week (1) beyond (1) beyond the crystal cave (1) bladelings (1) blink dog (1) bloody path (1) book of bantorra (1) broken bonds (1) brood mother (1) campaign setting (1) canian compact (1) card game (1) cards (1) carrion crawler (1) castle ravenloft (1) castles and crusades (1) castlevania (1) cavalier (1) celestia (1) celestials (1) centaur (1) chaladin (1) challenges (1) changlings (1) character optimization (1) chimera (1) chris perkins (1) chupacabra (1) church (1) city (1) city of the dead (1) clockwork horrors (1) cold (1) collaborate storytelling (1) combat superiority (1) comic (1) comics (1) comments (1) companion (1) con (1) conjuration (1) conquest of nerath (1) consistency (1) contest (1) controller (1) convention (1) conversion (1) corpse star (1) corruption (1) crosspost (1) cyclops (1) d and d xp (1) daggerdale (1) daggers (1) dagon (1) dark legacy of evard (1) dark sun campaign setting (1) dead by dawn (1) december (1) decisions (1) deck of many things (1) defender (1) deluxe dungeon master's screen (1) delves (1) demogorgron (1) description (1) design goals (1) disciplines (1) displacer beast (1) divine heroes (1) divine heroes 2 (1) dmg2 (1) dnd xp (1) don bassingthwaite (1) donation-ware (1) doppelganger (1) dorsen (1) draconomicon 2 (1) dragonfear (1) dresden files rpg (1) drider (1) dromite (1) dryad (1) dungeon delving (1) dungeon master's kit (1) dungeon survival handbook (1) dwarves (1) dying (1) earth domain (1) easy (1) eberron dragonshards (1) ecology of the hengeyokai (1) edge of the empire (1) edgewood (1) edition wars (1) elan (1) elder red dragon (1) elementals (1) escaped slave (1) ettin (1) event (1) evil campaigns (1) evocations (1) exploration (1) failed perceptions (1) fallout (1) faster combat (1) fate (1) fate points (1) features (1) february (1) feedback (1) fell taints (1) feral ghouls (1) fey beast tamer (1) fey pact (1) feydark (1) fiction (1) fireball (1) flavor (1) flesh golem (1) flgs (1) floating ability score (1) fomorians (1) forgotten realms player's guide (1) format (1) freeplay (1) frogs (1) fun (1) game balance (1) game mechancis (1) game report (1) game transparency (1) gates of neverdeath (1) gehreleth (1) genasi (1) genies (1) genre (1) giants (1) githyanki (1) githzerai (1) gloomwrought (1) gnolls (1) gnomes (1) goblin (1) goblinoid (1) goblinoids (1) god of war (1) going ape (1) golems (1) goliath (1) gorgon (1) grazzt (1) griffin (1) grimlock (1) guardinals (1) guilds and groups (1) halfing (1) halls of undermountain (1) harpy (1) hawkoid (1) headcrab (1) healer (1) healing surges (1) hell hound (1) heroes of legend (1) heroes of spell and sword (1) heroes of the elemental chaos (1) heroes of the fallen lands (1) hidden shrine of tamoachan (1) hierophant druid (1) high-level (1) hippogriff (1) hobgoblin (1) hook horror (1) hordeling (1) horizon (1) horse (1) house tharashk (1) howler wasp (1) huxtropy (1) hydra (1) icons (1) illusionist (1) images (1) impressions (1) inner planes (1) insider (1) invoker (1) isle of dread (1) item curses (1) january (1) january and beyond (1) kalashtar (1) kara-tur (1) katallos (1) keep on the borderlands (1) kenku (1) kord (1) kuo-toa (1) leader (1) legendary evils (1) level 3 (1) lich (1) live chat (1) location (1) lords of neverwinter (1) lords of shadow (1) madness at gardmore abbey (1) magazines (1) mage (1) magic and mystery (1) magic circles (1) magic missile (1) making race count (1) mark of nerath (1) martial heroes (1) martial heroes 4 (1) martial power (1) martial power 2 (1) martialist (1) medusa (1) melora (1) metallic dragons (1) mewcon (1) mimic (1) minotaurs (1) mithral dragon (1) modron (1) monadhan (1) monk basics (1) monkey (1) monkey bees (1) monster themes (1) monster tokens (1) monster updates (1) monsterous classes (1) monstrous class (1) monstrous races (1) moon catchers (1) moonshaes (1) mounted combat (1) mounts (1) moxie (1) mutations (1) nayaraj (1) nentir vale (1) neverwinter campaign setting (1) neverwinter game day (1) new feats (1) news (1) notes (1) november (1) november and beyond (1) npc (1) ogre (1) ogre mage (1) omega tech (1) oozes (1) orc (1) orcus (1) page 42 (1) panelist (1) paperback (1) pax east (1) pc (1) perception (1) player's handbook 2 (1) player's handbook races (1) player's strategy guide (1) players handbook 3 (1) plot (1) podcast (1) points of light (1) poster map (1) power cards (1) power sources (1) prayers (1) pregen (1) prestige classes (1) priest (1) primordial (1) prpg (1) ps3 (1) punjar (1) purple worm (1) pyramid of storms (1) pyromancer (1) questions (1) questions and answers (1) racial utilites (1) racial utilities (1) racial variants (1) raise dead (1) rarity (1) rat swarm (1) rebuttal (1) red box (1) reskinning (1) retarded (1) retro (1) return to blingdenstone (1) reward mechanics (1) rewards (1) robert (1) rogues (1) roper (1) rpgnet (1) rune soldier (1) runepriest (1) sacred 2 (1) sahuagin (1) sakuracon (1) samey (1) sandbox (1) satyr (1) scarrport (1) scorching burst (1) scoundrels (1) scout (1) seal of karga kul (1) seeker (1) sell (1) seminar (1) shadar-kai (1) shade (1) shadow (1) shadow magic (1) shapechanger (1) sharn (1) shields (1) shifter (1) side trek (1) six-pack (1) skeleton (1) skirmish game (1) slaad (1) slave barracks (1) slaves (1) solo (1) songblade (1) songbow (1) sooner dead (1) sorcerers (1) specialties (1) speculation (1) spell source (1) sphinx (1) spirit (1) staffs (1) star wars (1) stars (1) stat block (1) stick in the mud (1) stirge (1) strongholds (1) style (1) subclasses (1) summoner (1) supporting cast (1) survey (1) swamp (1) tactical (1) templar (1) temple of the weeping goddess (1) tenmei (1) the broken tower (1) the crawling fane (1) the fantasy cartographic (1) the five deadly shadows (1) the slaying stone (1) the spoony experiment (1) the tainted spiral (1) the twisted hall (1) things I learned (1) third-party material (1) thread (1) three dragon ante (1) tiers (1) tips (1) titan (1) tomb of horrors (1) top 10 (1) trailer (1) traits (1) troll (1) turaglas (1) turn undead (1) tuska (1) tutorial (1) under the crimson sun (1) undermountain (1) vancian magic (1) vestige (1) vestige pact (1) vryloka (1) war of horns (1) warden (1) wardens (1) warlock updates (1) warlocks (1) warpriest (1) weaponmaster (1) wererat (1) werewolf (1) whispering cairn (1) wight (1) wild shape (1) winter court (1) winter wolf (1) wish lists (1) wolf (1) worg (1) world serpent (1) wraith (1) wraith recon (1) yugoloths (1) zarash'ak (1) zombies (1)
 
Points of Light © 2011 DheTemplate.com & Main Blogger. Supported by Makeityourring Diamond Engagement Rings

You can add link or short description here