January 27, 2012

5th Edition: Jack is Back

2 comments
First things first, I got a shout out, made even cooler by the fact that I did not actively do anything to get it. While I had been aware of the RPG Carnival, seeing it here and there, though I am going to make a greater effort to follow it (as well as get featured).

Anywhoo according to the transcript from the Class Design seminar wizards are, at least currently, like 3rd Edition wizards near the end-run; they rely heavily on "Vancian" magic, but can take spell feats that give them at-wills, which remind me largely of Reserve feats from Complete Mage. While I am not a fan of daily resource management, at least rituals seem to still be intact. Rituals are great because it allows me to drop scrolls in adventures that anyone could use (which I did in the first A Sundered World session), as well as provide some flexibility to anyone that wanted to invest a feat.

One upside is that there is supposed to be a kind of "trade-in" mechanic, though I am not sure if it will allow wizards to cash in lower level spells for a higher one on the fly or as they level up. I know that somewhere it was said that fireball would deal a set 5d6 damage, and if you want to make it better you would slot it into a higher level. I like this idea because it would help greatly reduce the "power bloat". Some 4E powers did this, but not all, and I think that would allow a player to keep an iconic ability around without having to find another that works "close enough".

At least Bruce is on record for saying that they want classes to feel and play differently. In 3rd Edition wizards and sorcerers were too similar, what with sharing the same spell list. Though they tried to play up the bloodline angle later on with feat trees, it was not enough to diversify them. I feel that even 4th Edition did not go far enough, and I found it very difficult to properly evoke some sorcerer spell sources (especially dragon, which was the concept I theoretically should have enjoyed the most).

2 Responses so far.

  1. Hamel™ says:

    Pseudo-Vancian Magic has never gone away: they just called it Daily/Encounter Powers, in 4E.

    Anyway, 5E seems pretty interesting so far.

  2. True enough on both accounts.

Leave a Reply

Labels

review (87) Dragon (79) homebrew (68) eberron (44) character concepts (32) play report (32) Dungeon (29) game design (25) dark sun (24) essentials (24) aberrant (22) rant (22) DnD Essentials (21) at the mines of madness (20) class acts (20) preview (20) songs of erui (19) monsters (18) monster (17) playtest (17) shadow marches (16) heroes of shadow (15) legend and lore (15) report (15) excerpt (14) gamma world (14) mike mearls (14) the heirs of ruin (14) a sundered world (13) adventure (13) adventure path (13) DDI (12) ddm (12) tendrils of fate (12) winning races (12) feats (10) warlock (10) 5th edition (9) arcane power (9) goodman games (9) keep on the shadowfell (9) mapping (9) shardpit (9) thunderspire labyrinth (9) wizard (9) Athas (8) minis (8) races (8) the chaos scar (8) design and development (7) monster vault (7) new powers (7) powers (7) silent 7seven (7) skills (7) the shadows over greyshore (7) ampersand (6) beta (6) dnd encounters (6) druid (6) dungeons and dragons (6) forgotten realms (6) magic items (6) novel (6) previews (6) psion (6) ranger (6) revenant (6) themes (6) update (6) virtual table (6) adventure tools (5) artificer (5) board game (5) character builder (5) delve (5) ecology (5) familiars (5) heroes of the forgotten kingdoms (5) lair assault (5) living spell (5) map (5) maps (5) march of the phantom brigade (5) monk (5) monte cook (5) mordenkainen's magnificent mansion (5) psionic (5) sorcerer (5) tiefling (5) vampire (5) adamantine dragon (4) arcane (4) assassin (4) bard (4) calendar (4) campaign (4) clerics (4) creature incarnations (4) digital games (4) dungeon crawl classics (4) exploits (4) fighters (4) fortune cards (4) gamer's library (4) heroes of the feywild (4) hexblades (4) houserules (4) into dragon's den (4) mythbusting (4) online tools (4) ravenloft (4) rituals (4) rogue (4) rules (4) shaman (4) starter set (4) unearthed arcana (4) Scions of Punjar (3) adventure log (3) awesome (3) balic (3) barbarian (3) book of vile darkness (3) dangerous delves (3) divine power (3) dragon age (3) duergar (3) dungeon master (3) dungeon tiles (3) eberron player's guide (3) eladrin (3) encounters (3) errata (3) excerpts (3) fey (3) forum (3) game mechanics (3) gnome (3) greyshore (3) heroic tier (3) infernal pact (3) legends and lore (3) legion of gold (3) monster manual 2 (3) multiclass (3) neverwinter (3) paizo (3) paladin (3) pathfinder rpg (3) ph2 (3) ph3 (3) players handbook 2 (3) prerelease (3) primal (3) psionics (3) quori (3) rebuilding (3) roleplaying (3) star pact (3) summoning (3) terrain features (3) theme (3) tieflings (3) warforged (3) 4e (2) 4e conversion (2) Tokens (2) adventure format (2) anime (2) announcement (2) avenger (2) bards (2) beholders (2) bladesinger (2) blog (2) bloodlines (2) bullywugs (2) cairn of the winter king (2) channel divinity (2) character building (2) class (2) class compendium (2) closed beta (2) compilation (2) cosmic (2) critical failures (2) customization (2) dcc (2) death (2) debut (2) demonologist (2) demonomicon (2) divine (2) dming (2) domain of dread (2) dragonborn (2) dragonmarks (2) dungeoncraft (2) dwarf (2) edition (2) editorial (2) elf (2) epic destiny (2) episode (2) erui (2) executioner (2) expedition to castle ravenloft (2) famine in far-go (2) far realm (2) feywild (2) free rpg day (2) gencon (2) half-orc (2) hybrid (2) hybrid classes (2) interview (2) july (2) knight (2) knightfall games (2) know your role (2) kobold quarterly (2) martial (2) mechanics (2) mind flayer (2) modrons (2) monster builder (2) monster manual 3 (2) narrative (2) odnd (2) open grave (2) paragon path (2) pathfinder (2) pixie (2) play by post (2) player's handbook (2) player's handbook 3 (2) players handbook heroes (2) poll (2) power play (2) psionic power (2) psychic (2) raggamoffyn (2) random (2) rule-of-three (2) rust monster (2) sentinel (2) shaper (2) shardmind (2) skill challenges (2) slayer (2) table of contents (2) tendriles of fate (2) the hydra's grave (2) the shadowfell (2) the wayward wyrmling (2) updates (2) vampire class (2) warlord (2) web tools (2) wilden (2) wrath of ashardalon (2) 0-level characters (1) 2011 (1) 3rd Edition (1) Battlemaps (1) Burnt Offerings (1) Dragon 383 (1) Gond (1) Jaroo (1) MAD (1) NPCs (1) Theater (1) Timesus the black star (1) a heros first steps (1) ability score modifiers (1) ability scores (1) abyssal plague (1) accessory (1) adventurer's vault 2 (1) adventuring armies (1) advice (1) aerenal (1) against the giants (1) age of worms (1) alchemy (1) analysis (1) annoucements (1) april (1) april fools (1) arcane heroes (1) arcane heroes 3 (1) arcanist (1) archivist (1) ardent (1) arms race (1) art (1) asian (1) aspects (1) atari (1) august and beyond (1) avandra (1) background (1) banderhobb (1) barovia (1) bat (1) battle clerics (1) battlemind (1) bazaar of the bizarre (1) beard quills (1) beastmaster (1) beholder collector set (1) belgoi (1) best of the week (1) beyond (1) beyond the crystal cave (1) bloody path (1) book of bantorra (1) broken bonds (1) brood mother (1) canian compact (1) card game (1) cards (1) castle ravenloft (1) castles and crusades (1) castlevania (1) cavalier (1) chaladin (1) challenges (1) changlings (1) character optimization (1) character sheet (1) chris perkins (1) chupacabra (1) church (1) cold (1) collaborate storytelling (1) comic (1) comics (1) comments (1) companion (1) con (1) conjuration (1) conquest of nerath (1) consistency (1) controller (1) convention (1) conversion (1) corruption (1) crosspost (1) d and d xp (1) daggerdale (1) daggers (1) dagon (1) dark legacy of evard (1) dark sun campaign setting (1) dead by dawn (1) december (1) decisions (1) deck of many things (1) defender (1) deluxe dungeon master's screen (1) delves (1) description (1) deva (1) devil (1) disciplines (1) divine heroes (1) divine heroes 2 (1) dmg2 (1) dnd xp (1) don bassingthwaite (1) donation-ware (1) dorsen (1) draconomicon 2 (1) dragonfear (1) dragons (1) dresden files rpg (1) dromite (1) drow (1) dryad (1) dungeon master's kit (1) dwarves (1) dying (1) earth domain (1) easy (1) eberron dragonshards (1) ecology of the hengeyokai (1) edgewood (1) edition wars (1) elan (1) elder red dragon (1) elemental chaos (1) escaped slave (1) event (1) evil campaigns (1) evocations (1) failed perceptions (1) fallout (1) fate (1) fate points (1) features (1) february (1) feedback (1) fell taints (1) feral ghouls (1) fey beast tamer (1) fey pact (1) feydark (1) fiction (1) fireball (1) flavor (1) flesh golem (1) flgs (1) floating ability score (1) fomorians (1) forgotten realms player's guide (1) format (1) freeplay (1) frogs (1) fun (1) game balance (1) game mechancis (1) game transparency (1) gates of neverdeath (1) genasi (1) genre (1) gith (1) gloomwrought (1) gnoll (1) gnomes (1) goblins (1) god of war (1) going ape (1) goliath (1) guilds and groups (1) halfing (1) hawkoid (1) headcrab (1) healer (1) heroes of legend (1) heroes of spell and sword (1) heroes of the elemental chaos (1) heroes of the fallen lands (1) hidden shrine of tamoachan (1) hierophant druid (1) hordeling (1) horse (1) house tharashk (1) howler wasp (1) human (1) huxtropy (1) icons (1) illusionist (1) images (1) impressions (1) insider (1) invoker (1) item curses (1) january (1) january and beyond (1) kalashtar (1) kara-tur (1) katallos (1) keep on the borderlands (1) kenku (1) kord (1) leader (1) legendary evils (1) level 3 (1) lords of neverwinter (1) lords of shadow (1) lycanthrope (1) madness at gardmore abbey (1) magazines (1) mage (1) magic and mystery (1) magic circles (1) magic missile (1) making race count (1) mark of nerath (1) martial heroes (1) martial heroes 4 (1) martial power (1) martial power 2 (1) martialist (1) melora (1) mewcon (1) minotaur (1) minotaurs (1) mithral dragon (1) monadhan (1) monk basics (1) monkey (1) monkey bees (1) monster themes (1) monster tokens (1) monster updates (1) monsterous classes (1) monstrous class (1) monstrous races (1) moon catchers (1) moonshaes (1) morale (1) mounted combat (1) mounts (1) moxie (1) mummy (1) mutations (1) nayaraj (1) nentir vale (1) neverwinter campaign setting (1) neverwinter game day (1) new feats (1) news (1) notes (1) november (1) november and beyond (1) npc (1) omega tech (1) orcus (1) otyugh (1) owlbear (1) page 42 (1) panelist (1) paperback (1) pc (1) perception (1) player's handbook 2 (1) player's handbook races (1) player's strategy guide (1) players handbook 3 (1) plot (1) points of light (1) poster map (1) power cards (1) power sources (1) prayers (1) pregen (1) primordial (1) prpg (1) ps3 (1) punjar (1) purple worm (1) pyramid of storms (1) pyromancer (1) questions (1) race (1) racial utilites (1) racial utilities (1) racial variants (1) raise dead (1) rarity (1) rat swarm (1) rebuttal (1) red box (1) red dragon (1) reskinning (1) retarded (1) retro (1) reward mechanics (1) rewards (1) robert (1) rpgnet (1) rune soldier (1) runepriest (1) sacred 2 (1) sakuracon (1) samey (1) sandbox (1) scarrport (1) scorching burst (1) scoundrels (1) scout (1) seal of karga kul (1) seeker (1) sell (1) shade (1) shadow (1) shadow magic (1) sharn (1) shields (1) shifter (1) six-pack (1) skeleton (1) skirmish game (1) slave barracks (1) slaves (1) solo (1) songblade (1) songbow (1) sooner dead (1) sorcerers (1) speculation (1) spell source (1) spells (1) spirit (1) staffs (1) star cult (1) stars (1) stick in the mud (1) strongholds (1) style (1) summoner (1) supporting cast (1) swamp (1) templar (1) temple of the weeping goddess (1) tenmei (1) the broken tower (1) the crawling fane (1) the fantasy cartographic (1) the five deadly shadows (1) the slaying stone (1) the spoony experiment (1) the tainted spiral (1) the twisted hall (1) things I learned (1) thread (1) three dragon ante (1) tips (1) tomb of horrors (1) top 10 (1) trailer (1) treasure parcels (1) turaglas (1) tuska (1) tutorial (1) under the crimson sun (1) vestige (1) vestige pact (1) vryloka (1) war of horns (1) warden (1) wardens (1) warlock updates (1) warlocks (1) warpriest (1) weaponmaster (1) weapons (1) wererat (1) whispering cairn (1) wild shape (1) winter court (1) wish lists (1) wizards (1) wolf (1) wraith recon (1) zarash'ak (1) zombies (1)
 
Points of Light © 2011 DheTemplate.com & Main Blogger. Supported by Makeityourring Diamond Engagement Rings

You can add link or short description here